Communicated on 16 January 2020

Published on 3 February 2020

 

FOURTH SECTION

Application no. 20081/19
Florin BUHUCEANU and Victor CIOBOTARU against Romania
and 12 other applications
(see list appended)

SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASES

The applicants are same sex couples who complain that the Romanian legislation does not allow them to get married or to enter into any other type of civil union and thus they are being discriminated against as a result of their sexual orientation and disadvantaged by the lack of legal recognition of their relationship. They invoke Article 8 taken alone and in conjunction with Article 14 of the Convention.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

1.  Has there been a violation of the applicants right to respect for their private and family life contrary to Article 8 of the Convention? In particular, should they be afforded a possibility to have their relationship recognised by law (see Oliari and Others v. Italy, nos. 18766/11 and 36030/11, 21 July 2015)?

 

2.  Have the applicants suffered discrimination in the enjoyment of their Convention rights on the ground of their sexual orientation, contrary to Article 14 of the Convention read in conjunction with Article 8 of the Convention, in respect of their inability to get married or enter into any other type of legally recognised union?


APPENDIX

No.

Application no.

Lodged on

Applicant

Birth year

Place of Residence

Nationality

Represented by

1.

20081/19

10/04/2019

Florin BUHUCEANU

1971

Bucharest

Romanian

 

Victor CIOBOTARU

1987

Bucharest

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

2.

20108/19

10/04/2019

A.A.N.

1972

Bucharest

Romanian

 

M.M.I.

1980

Bucharest

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

3.

20115/19

10/04/2019

M.P.

1989

Brașov

Romanian

 

G.I.T.

1984

Bucharest

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

4.

20122/19

10/04/2019

Voicu-Dan DRAGOMIR

1983

Cernica

Romanian

 

Oliver ULERICH

1997

Petroșani

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

5.

20129/19

10/04/2019

G.C.C.

1974

Bucharest

Romanian

 

G.R.B.

1974

Bucharest

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

6..

20134/19

10/04/2019

A.T.S.

1979

Bucharest

Romanian

 

I.P.

1994

Târgu Mureș

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

7.

20140/19

10/04/2019

A.F.S.

1990

Bucharest

Romanian

 

S.G.M.

1990

Bucharest

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

8.

55037/19

18/10/2019

B.C.

1989

Bucharest

Romanian

 

I.I.C.

1987

Bucharest

Romanian

 

 

 

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

9.

55041/19

18/10/2019

A.M.

1986

Brașov

Romanian

 

C.E.F.

1978

Brașov

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

10.

55045/19

18/10/2019

M.C.R.

1967

Brașov

Romanian

 

R.V.F.

1999

Dăișoara

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

11.

55047/19

18/10/2019

V.A.B.

1994

Bucharest

Romanian

 

M.A.D.

1988

Bucharest

Romanian

 

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

12.

55049/19

18/10/2019

R.M.M.

1990

Urlați

Romanian

 

I.A.P.

1996

Dioști

Romanian

 

 

Raluca Iustina IONESCU

13.

55051/19

18/10/2019

G.C.P.

1982

Otopeni

Romanian

 

F.S.

1979

Bucharest

Romanian

Raluca Iustina IONESCU